My Letter to Michael Machado
[My letter to Senator Machado after he walked out of the Senate hearing on SB 861 after he voted yes. I faxed it to him this morning.]
Dear Senator Machado;
I had the opportunity last night to watch the recording of the Senate hearing for SB 861 (Speier) – [Animals: Dogs: Spay, Neuter, & Breeding Programs]. I was excited for the opportunity to hear those who spoke for and against the bill; they were all very passionate about their position as this bill hits very close to home for many people. I am personally opposed to this bill for various reasons I will discuss later. A friend of mine spoke against the bill, as a lawyer and an owner of a therapy dog who happens to be an American Pit Bull Terrier, she is very knowledgeable of the impact this bill could have on dog owners. Unfortunately you were not there to hear her. You chose to walk out of the meeting after only hearing those who supported the bill and one person who was against it. Not only did you walk out, but you rudely interrupted a deaf woman in order to do so. What was so important that you had to leave in the middle of the Senate hearing for this bill? You represent me and all your other constituents and have the responsibility to attend these hearings and thoughtfully consider all sides before voting; listening to those who take the time to attend and speak at these hearings is part of that. I voted for you last November because you promised to do what was best for the people of this constituency and you have failed to do so. I am not only upset how you voted for this bill, but that you didn’t even stay to hear all sides of the issue.
We have a vicious dog law on the books that would be very effective if it was enforced. Included in this law is a provision that does not allow for any breed specific legislation. This was thoughtfully placed in this law to prevent future laws from being passed out of emotion and in quick response to a tragedy. It is in place so that we will take the time to consider and implement laws that work and don’t discriminate or take away our civil liberties. As soon as we repeal this portion of the law nobody can guarantee that future breed specific legislation won’t be passed, including outright bans or ridiculous requirements like muzzling or large amounts of insurance coverage. I agree that there is an over population problem but that is not why this bill is being pushed; this bill is being pushed in response to a twelve year old boy being killed by his dog because of the irresponsible actions of his mother. This bill could not have prevented his death and will not prevent future tragedies. This bill is also being pushed so that Senator Speier can push her own political agenda-a future run at Lt. Governor. I am appalled that my rights as a dog owner take second to her own political career in an attempt to rescue us from “evil” pit bulls.
My partner and I adopted our American Pit Bull Terrier from the SPCA. He is the best thing in our life; he brings us such joy and comfort. He is sweet, loving, affectionate, and gentle, all standard to the majority of American Pit Bull Terriers. If we pass mandatory spay & neuter laws only for pit bulls we will loose a wonderful breed of dog. Only those who are already breeding dogs without consideration for their temperament will do so illegally. Breeding will be driven underground and there will be a huge black market for pit bulls; all bred for the wrong reasons [large head size, color, etc.]. We will no longer have dogs like our Jack, who have an amazing temperament and disposition.
I am so disappointed in your conduct regarding the hearing of this bill. If there was an emergency or something that was so much more important I’d love to hear what that was. I can’t imagine what is more important that doing your job representing your constituents at these hearings.
Thank you,
Kymberli Martinez
Proud owner of an American Pit Bull Terrier










